From: "Ray Lutz, Citizens' Oversight" To: sfvote@sfgov.org Cc: raylutz@citizensoversight.org Date: November 16, 2026, 22:45 UTC Subject: Batches scanned twice in the November 5, 2024 General Election Attachment: CitizensOversight_SanFrancisco_Repeated_Batches_Letter.pdf, 414,461 bytes Dear Mr. Arntz, Please find attached our letter on batches of ballots that were scanned twice in the November 5, 2024 General Election in San Francisco. In brief, our AuditEngine review of sheet 1 found six batches, 335 ballots, that were scanned twice and are included twice in the cast vote records. We found three more batches whose second scans appear only in the ballot images. Appendix A of the letter lists each pair of batches. We are bringing this to your attention now, so you can check the 2026 election before certification. Based on our analysis, the outcome of any contest is not in question for 2024. The letter is also online at https://copswiki.org/Common/M2070 The supporting reports are here: Repeated batch report: https://us-east-1-audit-engine-jobs.s3.amazonaws.com/US/CA/CA_SanFrancisco_20241105_sheet1/reports/Repeated_Batch_Report.html Reconciliation report: https://us-east-1-audit-engine-jobs.s3.amazonaws.com/US/CA/CA_SanFrancisco_20241105_sheet1/reports/Reconciliation_Report.html We would be glad to schedule a virtual meeting to present our system and results, and to help with a quick review of the 2026 election. Sincerely, Raymond Lutz Executive Director, Citizens' Oversight mktg@citizensoversight.org (619) 784-6268